Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Questioning and Comprehension

Here are two great books to use when you're teaching questioning to your students. Have them preview the book and ask "before reading questions". Remind them that good readers don't always find answers to their questions. Sometimes, though, the questions are what keep us reading and understanding. If you can ask a meaningful question, then it demonstrates that you are really thinking.

In The Wise Woman and Her Secret, the little girl in the book is taught to keep "wandering and wondering". It's a great way to help readers understand that we do the same thing as we read: We wander through the book and wonder about characters, setting, problems, and solutions. This book is beautifully illustrated and is probably best-used with students in grades 2 and higher.

Have students make a list of their own questions from before, during and after reading. They can put them on sticky notes and post them on a chart paper labeled, "Before, During, and After". Let them compare and contrast.

The second book was once a popular "war-song" by Peter, Paul and Mary. It is called, "Day is Done". Have students listen for the questions presented by the singer as well as the child. Then have them ask their own questions.
The book includes a CD in the back with the song on it. (Note: I like the original Peter, Paul and Mary version much better as it is a bit faster.)

Still readers love listening to songs made into books. It's a great way to discuss interpretation as well.

Remember to teach your readers that there are meaningful questions and "fluff questions". Readers must be asking about the deeper meaning of a book if it's going to help their comprehension. Those surface-level questions (what color was the character's shirt?) are OK, but they generally don't lead to more understanding.

Happy Questioning!


Anonymous said...

Dear Susan,

My name is Jill Randolph and I work with CityTownInfo.com, a website providing over 50,000 reference pages of real-world information on careers, communities, and colleges to our 10 million annual visitors.

I was reviewing your blog and wanted to let you know that we have just released a free 64-page e-book we think you and your visitors may find interesting. Our e-book provides a candid, real-world perspective on the elementary teaching profession via interviews with 25 teachers from grades 1 through 5, across a variety of disciplines including reading specialists, PE, and music teachers, to name a few. The book offers advice, tips, best and worst parts of the job, as well as words of wisdom, inspiration and caution from working teachers. One quote from the book:

"Many people think that because the school day ends at 3 PM teachers just leave, but, the truth is, we stay late and often put in more than an eight-hour day. Almost always we take work home with us. Yes, we do have summers off, but we are constantly thinking about the school year to come and working on our skills."

Yours is one of the very first blogs we are reaching out to, so that you may share this relevant information with your visitors. We hope you’ll take a bit of time to review the book – it’s a fairly quick read – and then consider passing along your thoughts to your readers. We can provide you with cover art images in various sizes if you would like and we recommend linking to the page containing the eBook (http://www.citytowninfo.com/employment/elementary-school-teachers).

Thank you for your time and consideration. If I can answer any questions you may have, please don't hesitate to contact me.


Jill Randolph


Anonymous said...

Hеllo i am kavin, itѕ my fiгst ocсasiоn tο commentіng anywherе,
ωhеn i геad thіѕ poѕt
і thοught i could also create сomment ԁue to thіѕ brillіant

Have a looκ at mу ωeb blоg .
.. Car insurance for new drivers

Anonymous said...

It's remarkable designed for me to have a web site, which is helpful designed for my know-how. thanks admin

Have a look at my weblog ... 1 Day Car Insurance

Anonymous said...

Hurrаh, that's what I was exploring for, what a material! present here at this website, thanks admin of this web page.

Feel free to surf to my web blog - www.Ukinsurancewise.co.uk

Anonymous said...

Hey there this is somewhat οf off tοpic but I
was wаnting to knοw іf blogs use WYSIWYG еdіtors
or іf yοu have to manually сοde with HTϺL.
Ι'm starting a blog soon but have no coding knowledge so I wanted to get advice from someone with experience. Any help would be greatly appreciated!

My web site: Any Driver Car Insurance

Anonymous said...

Hаvе уοu eνer consideгed about іncluding a little bit morе than just your artіcles?
I mean, what you ѕay iѕ ѵаluablе and all.
But thіnk of if you аdded sоme gгеаt graphics oг videоs to gіvе уour ρosts mοre, "pop"!
Your cоntеnt іѕ eхcellеnt but ωith images anԁ νideo
clipѕ, this blog could dеfinіtеly bе onе of thе
bеst іn itѕ nichе. Wonderful blog!

my web-site - http://www.ukinsurancewise.co.uk/the-cost-of-car-insurance-for-new-drivers-does-not-need-to-be-high/

Anonymous said...

Your method of telling all in this aгtiсle іs genuinely good,
all be able to without ԁiffіcultу bе aωare of it, Τhanks a lot.

my webpаge ... Daily car insurance